ELF DREAM

lien vers version française Voir cette page en français lien vers version française

History:
pains and repression of virtual life

October 29, 2021. Given the ongoing events, the content may change

by Yichard Muni, elf bard

 

 

(Permalink) Due to 3D web sites being much more complex than 2D sites, we are dependent on «world owners», special software, competing standards, etc. Then repression can interfere by removing one of these software, or a world owner can go wonky with social biases, bad management, etc.

This page is telling what happened in most cases, as a duty of memory: future people will need to know the pangs and repression virtual life had to go through, in the early times. Just as democracy, which looks natural, but which had to be imposed through many tortuous ways and hard-fought battles, explained in school books.

Also, as in the former Wild West, there still are (2021) no laws and no justice in the virtual. Then our only defense is exposing and denouncing. If persons are named, sorry for them, but they just had to be correct (and for some, to follow my advice)

This page is arranged in loose historical order:

VRML -- Deuxième Monde -- Second Life -- Virtual murder -- The repression of virtual worlds -- Open Sims -- Inworldz -- Discovery Grid -- Rebirth of halcyon -- Sovaria Estates

 

How it all started: the VRML

(Permalink) The first time ever I saw a virtual scene was in summer 1997, when I was doing a retreat in the Nalanda Monastery. The monks showed me a virtual mandala, still cartoonish by today standards. This was a revelation: virtual worlds would allow to share the experience of the immersion in a better world! This is how virtual life became one of my main focuses.

Soon after I understood that I could do myself such virtual scenes, with simple means that I could easily afford and appropriate: an Internet site, the VRML file format, the Cortona viewer ad the ISB 3D modeler, the two later being made by the Russian company Parallel Graphics.

We were still alone with these worlds, with no visible appearance. But this was far enough for my project. This is how I created several scenes of the world of the Eolis, or the world of Dumria.

Soon after, the Blaxxun project (formerly Black Sun), introduced appearances, together with a chat system, allowing to meet other visitors, and interact with them. Virtual life had started! This still was very simple and appropriable, since the scenes were still stored on our own 2D web site, the Blaxxun viewer ensuring the animations and the characters. Things were taking shape, and I even started to earn some notoriety with the quality of my scenes.

Yet we barely hear about VRML today. What happened? This wonderful technology was... abandoned. Yes you read well. There was no unforeseen problem, no censorship, no political crackdown. Just that, one day, parallel Graphics announced they will stop bettering Cortona and ISB. And on two dozens projects of viewers, nobody was able to provide something as complete and easy to install as Cortona!! Blaxxun side, they... closed. Despite the «support» of several large companies, not less than General Electric, BMW, Deutsche Bank, IBM, Canal+, Siemens, Intel, etc. none of which was able to foresee the numerous uses of virtual worlds.

What probably happened is that all these companies found more lucrative to sell the complete scenes, instead of the tools to make them. But for this they had to hide the tools.

Most likely, they realized that virtual life is the most uncontrollable space of freedom. This is why the system will never support virtual worlds. Hence the interest of fostering independent and open-source projects, like Halcyon.

Users side, only Blaxxun allowed to actually meet people, and the experience was too short to really organize a community of users. I had some good contacts, but it also appeared that «griefers» (morons coming in to disturb) would be an heavy issue. To the point that a friendly Blaxxun place closed, after several visits by black suited morons accusing them of «immorality». The worse case was on Web3D-fr, the French reference chat for the VRML. Here I received a heavy attack of religious intolerance. All the present users took part in the attack, showing that they already did that several times, discouraging all the other users. One of my attackers, a maternalist-authoritarian hiding under the pseudonym of Wildpeaks, probably denigrated me in the US, contributing to discourage developers of alternatives to Cortona and Blaxxun. Web3D-fr finally... closed, when the owner had to bear the terrible «attack» of... an homosexual proposal! Sometimes the Karma must have a lot of fun.

So we had to wait for Second life to have an interesting virtual life. But for most people, Second Life is way too expensive to allow for real creativity, and places there exist only if some rich person can afford $300 a month for a leisure.

 

The Deuxième Monde

(Permalink) The Deuxième Monde was created in 1997 by the right-wing French media Canal+, using the VRML technology and the Blaxxun engine. It was the first virtual community open to the general public. Although its content was severely limited (A reconstruction of Paris, which users could not modify).

I only approached the Deuxième Monde very briefly: I tried to enter in, but there were so many ads in the welcome place that we could not move around without clicking on one (which at the time resulted in a punishment of minutes of useless web page loading).

The Deuxième Monde was shut down without notice or any way for users to keep in touch, beginning a cycle of repression and of virtual murders, which is still going on when I created this page twenty years later (2021).

Canal+ never explained its disastrous action. But the most likely thing is that, since the purpose of the media is to subjugate, they could not stand the freedom that virtual worlds offer.

 

Second Life

(Permalink) When I first tried Second Life, in 2006, I immediately saw it was an important thing. Not only it was popular, but in more it had unique features: groups with management tools, and an in-world building system. Nobody seems to understand the importance of simple tools for the appropriation of virtual life, and indeed nobody imitated Second Life (save of course Open Sims). These tools undoubtedly are what made the success of Second Life, over many alternatives existing by the time: not only everybody could have a virtual life, but in more even people with low skills could appropriate it and build their own environment! And, basically, Second Life was not a video game: there was no imposed purposes or competition.

The drawbacks were numerous, though. First, and mostly, the excruciating prices made that only rich people could hold significant land (actually land costs nothing in the virtual. But the number of objects it contains costs server load, as in any shared web hosting). Ordinary persons could only have small parcels, so that most of us were dependent of large groups created by a small number of rich people (able to spend $1000 to $2000 a month for a leisure!)

This collection of small plots with incompatible projects made of the mainlands a chaos of random constructions, often with dark textures reflecting the bad taste of their creators. The only nice places were some privately owned regions.

 

The years 2006 to 2008 were fantastic years: Second Life was growing at an extraordinary speed, and every day was seeing new initiatives of groups or institutions appropriating the virtual: companies, merchants (demonstrations), artists, public institutions (several governments had created real embassies) and politicians (unfortunately not the best: Ségolène Royal and Jean Marie Le Pen). It was feeling as if a revolution was taking place, where the virtual was everywhere and was accepted in the mainstream society. People were loving the «Lindens» (staff of Linden Labs, the company running Second Life).

There were real institutions, with for example a network of Tibetan temples, a mosque, or a reconstruction of the Koln Cathedral, managed by its real clergy. Plus the Science Center, where I could talk with real scientists, visit a collection of all the existing rockets, and even the Cape Canaveral VAB, all life-sized!

I had during this period extraordinary and very enriching experiences, in a group of Elves called Elf Circle, which possessed the most beautiful places of Second Life, thanks to a rich «queen» paying each month for several autonomous regions. Even the problem of the «griefers» (omnipresent in Second Life at that time) had been solved by «guardians», of which I was one, who practiced a form of respectful non-violence. But we were effective, and the griefers were scared when we arrived!

Then, in 2008... everything started to rot. Everything, not just this or that part.

On the Elves side, the «queen» entrusted the management of the place to a guy dressed as an elf, but in fact devious and hostile, the infamous Kivaniel Adria. In a few months he managed to chase away half of the group, before I realized the harm he was doing, when he came after me. Unfortunately the «queen» never took my warnings, and Elf Circle went into a downward spiral, only to disappear a few years later. Sad end of one of the greatest marvels of Second Life.

On the Lindens side, they took several catastrophic decisions, including to remove the entry-level offers (2008), confining Second Life into a rich bourgeois milieu. The bug reporting system had become a hazing place, with «triagers» who closed the requests at random. Thus, in a few months, the residents began to hate the Lindens, for so many absurd decisions, virtual murders without motive, etc.

On the side of external repression, this is where the accusation of pedophilia came in (there was only one in the press, and vague) which served as a pretext for the media to start denigrating Second Life, which became the object of their mockery. Then they ignored it, their sabotage mission accomplished.

This deleterious atmosphere also made the companies which invested in the new space flee, closing the trap and isolating Second Life in a «sex and leisure» ghetto for rich people without any project or ideal.

In some months (2009) the phenomenal growth of Second Life became a sheer downfall, and nobody gave it more than one or two years before closing.

In 2013, they added insult to injury with their incredible TOS article 2.3 (excerp): «Except as prohibited by law, you hereby waive, and you agree to waive, any moral rights (including attribution and integrity) that you may have in any User Content, even if it is altered or changed in a manner not agreeable to you.» Useless to say, many creators left, and I myself not uploaded a single pixed there, toward what was widely described as an Intellectual property theft. This article was removed since, but we wonder why Second Life did not closed for good with this one.

In fact, Second Life is still there today (2021), with even some very nice stuff. But it owes it to a very particular economic niche: rich people able to pay hundreds of dollars a month for a hobby. This niche keeps it afloat, but as it is saturated, Second Life has no real growth anymore.

Second Life also tried to modernize itself, with Sansar. But the latter had no construction tools, and no way to transfer our objects. So it was a failure in a few weeks. The Linden even not learned from their own success.

 

Virtual murders

(Permalink) Despite the brevity of the Deuxième Monde experience, people still had time to form friendships and even loves. The brutal and unpredictable closure of the Deuxième Monde put an abrupt end to this sentimental life, separating friends and lovers forever, with no hope of reunion.

It thus appeared at this occasion, that despite the virtual worlds being virtual, people living these have real feelings. And the suppression of a virtual character creates as much suffering as a physical murder. Hence this expression of «virtual murder», which I think is nor an exaggeration, neither a video game word.

Warning unheeded, virtual murder became a system in Second life, where a simple accusation (of pedophilia of course) is enough to be expelled without notice, and without means nor to recover our possessions neither to contact our friends. I knew a very serious case, of a severely disabled woman: Second Life was her only way to have a normal social life. She committed suicide some days after being expelled on a false accusation, without any investigation or appeal. The word «murder» is nor a style effect neither a Godwin point: there was a real death. I myself was a victim of this method in Discovery Grid, at the expense of my scientific projects.

This is why I asked, as early as 2009 in the Virtual Worlds Manifesto, for an inalienable virtual identity, independent of Internet hosts and world owners. This is also valid for our possessions, which must remain... in our possession. In the physical world, these rights are recognized even for the worse criminals. In the virtual world, we... wait.

Some will go as far as to demand laws and courts for virtual exaction. Unfortunately, laws and courts bring their own risks: in a space of freedom and spontaneous Elven magic, they are like elephants in a china store. Some common sense is therefore far better. Otherwise, we shall have virtual courts sooner or later. With the corresponding closure of many forms of freedom.

 

The repression of virtual worlds.

(Permalink) The word «repression» may seem exaggerated: there is no legal ban, no politician ranting, no police violence against virtual worlds, as there are against ecology. But there is a sneaky atmosphere of hostile decisions and tricked vocabulary spreading confusion.

-Pretending not to know.

The most common reaction while talking about virtual worlds, are blank stares, sometimes a small embarrassed smile, as if 25 years after the start, people were still not knowing. In reality, they know very well, but they confuse with:

-The confusion with video games

On the other hand, everyone knows very well video games, which are virtual worlds specialized in fighting opponents, in an imposed environment. Submission and competition, everything the system expects from us. It is therefore understandable that we are bombarded with information about video games, while maintaining silence about other virtual worlds. A perfect example of newspeak, to divert people from real virtual life, and reduce their experience to a lousy competition.

The difference goes far: on the same computer, the quality and speed of video game browsers are 10 to 100 times higher, there are billions of investments, large shelves in stores, special computers, etc. Thus, the real virtual worlds, the ones where we define our own purposes, are in contrast violently ostracized.

-Accusations of pedophilia.

Yes, there have been, against Second life, to the point that for many, virtual world has remained associated with pedophilia. Yet it is explicitly forbidden in all publicly accessible virtual worlds. So they bring out the sexual freedom which takes place in some places in Second Life... Sexual freedom is probably what itches the most the sickos of purposeless repression. I have seen people outraged that we can wear a penis in Second Life. If they knew that I wear one every day, in the physical world...

-If it is in the virtual, it would not be important, it would be without conséquences

I am sorry, but in the virtual, we are persons, with our sensitivity and our objectives. To indulge in stalking, sexual assaults, or to destroy our world, is as serious as in the physical world, and it should entail the same punishment.

-Virtual world are 3D helmets with a dinosaur pouncing on us

All the demos show that, or zombies, sometimes tennis. The media even openly insists that this is virtual reality. But if we start talking about elves, we suddenly hear a loud, embarrassed silence.

-3D headsets, or screen?

Another scam is to say that virtual reality is 3D headsets. In fact, nothing has really changed since 1997: I am still watching my scenes with the normal computer screen. 3D headsets are like nuclear fusion: medias are speaking of them, politicians are talking about them, it is the future, etc. But after all the talks, we are still not seeing plug and play headsets, options for headsets in 3D browsers, adaptation to our eyesight, virtual keyboard, force feedback, etc.

-Unsuitable Internet standards

The Internet was initially designed mainly to exchange texts. Even images were not immediately imposed, only just before the general public Net (1997).

Today, much more is required from the Internet: sounds, interactive animations (See bottom notes here on the Flash epic, now replaced by HTML5), movies, speech, video conferencing, etc. Until now, everything was done with the http:// protocol, by packets sent on the net and arriving when they could, at random, or not at all. It was enough to «buffer» (wait for all the packets to arrive, with a slight delay) to display a voice or a video which looks continuous, even if the elements arrived in a disorder.

However, this method no longer works with applications which require real time: telepresence, telesurgery, remote driving, industrial process control and... virtual worlds. Indeed, the later use processes which are all faster than the slightly delayed http://. The result is an ugly and often disabling «jitter» of virtual scenes: can you imagine a car, or worse a scalpel, dancing a jig? For this reason, I proposed in 2009 the nrmp://, which sends all the packets in order, on paths connected in advance at the level of the routers. I even submitted a paper for a symposium on the virtual. And guess what: the paper was rejected. And since, you never heard anything similar. Not even a plagiarism, nothing of nothing.

Virtual train using nrmp:// Virtual train using http://

 

 

 

 

 

Left, my virtual train as we would see it with nrmp://, right as we see it with http:// (exaggerated, but sometimes it is really as bad). (The clouds are not part of this demo, it is a Second Life thing that everybody imitated without wiondering if we want them)

 

What is the best way available today
to vieww virtual worlds.

(Permalink) As a reply to the previous attacks on the screens, I allow myself with this modest evaluation. Considering the hardware actually available today, the most pragmatic solution would be the following:

-A curved high definition screen, about one meter in front of us

-Glasses adapted to your eyesight, with their punctum remotum on the screen

-A PC capable of driving such a screen, worth about 1000-1200 euros (super-graphic card)

-A keyboard and a mouse in normal position

-We can be sitting, or standing to «walk». In the second case, the keyboard is on a shelf at chest height.

-To «walk», a USB pedalboard. You can find some rectangular ones with three pedals around one hundred euros, to be connected to the arrow keys of the keyboard. Ideally, we should create some wide enough for both feet, with a fourth pedal to go backwards.

The whole thing would be worth about 2200 euros. We thus understand why this is not yet democratized. But it is almost as immersive as the helmet, with the added freedom to get out of the immersion, write notes, etc. Above all, we can «walk», and therefore to feel in your body!

If we compare, the 3D headset are much cheaper. But there is no miracle, miniaturization comes at the price of a decrease in resolution, comfort, etc.

 

Open Sims

(Permalink) Open Sims appeared around 2008, as a «free» alternative to Second Life, on the same principle as Linux. It was made possible by the fact that Second Life made its browser open source, allowing to recreate a simulator by reverse engineering. It is rumored that a team from IBM wrote the original simulator, but this is not flattering for this company, because this simulator was written with the feet, full of bugs, incomplete implementations, software inconsistencies.

But the most vicious thing is that the Open Sim developers' team is affected by a form of Marxism, which makes them accept or reject technical improvements depending on the supposed political opinions of those who propose them. In theory, Open Sims intends to be a free and collaborative world, where creations are freely shared. Unfortunately, the Open Sims tools are often used by thieves to appropriate our creations, and even to claim being the creators! Typical scene in Open Sims: an adorable, almost naked young woman suddenly appears in your region, serving you «honey» and «darling», offering you «gifts» of dozens of items (actually stolen), and... she disappears never to return.

 

Inworldz

(Permalink) Inworldz started as an Open Sims world among the others. However, it differed from them in its absolute abiding to intellectual property laws. This stance quickly led to hostility from the main Open Sims developers. Moreover, the creators, Beth Reisll (Elenia llewelyn) and David Daeshler (Tranquility Dexler) soon realized that the lousy Open Sims software was not working, they even had to disconnect the physics!

Fortunately David is a talented programmer, and with the help of Jim Tarber and Balpien Hammerer, they started to improve the simulator. The project being open source, they naturally passed on these improvements to the Open Sims developers. But the latter... refused to integrate them! For... political reasons: the abiding to copyright laws, which some Open Sims people hate. For them Inworldz was a class enemy! I find extremely despicable to pretend to be anti-system, only to give birth to another system, even more stupid, narrow-minded and repressive.

 

So Inworldz evolved their own simulator, which they ended up calling Halcyon, thus distinguishing themselves from Open Sims. Quickly it became much better quality, especially in terms of scripts and physics.

The years 2011-2018 in Inworldz were wonderful, with incredible virtual creations, a united community and lots of activities. However, finding no more suitable elf groups in which to promote my ideal, I ended up creating my own group, Elf Dream (the topic of this site). I started to hold weekly meetings, often with another artist, Illianor Illios, a harpist and singer with an angelic voice.

The directors also organized several festivals each year, which allowed me to work as if I had my own region. This is how appeared my virtual trains, with my vitual «company», «YichTrains Elven Works», made possible by the much better quality of Inworldz, which far surpassed Open Sims and even Second Life. My trains could only work there! My greatest satisfaction was to see a group of «Virual Ability» using my trains (A group of disabled people looking for a normal life in the virtual, one of the greatest beauties of the thing)

I ended up with my own small but compact plot of land in a region owned by another Second Life Elf defector, Fleure Homewood. It was years of friendship, beauty and creation.

 

Sadly forum disputes, media silence, and denigration by some Open Sims ideologists eventually undermined Inworldz, leading to its end without notice in 2018. It was a huge grief, quite comparable to real deaths (some of us disappeared from the net) I detail what happened here.

 

Discovery Grid

(Permalink) When Inworldz crashed in 2018, we had no other alternatives than one or the other lesser quality Open Sims. When I saw that Balpien Hammerer (Rene Vega, several homonyms) was involved in «Discovery Grid» management, I thought it was a good choice.

I knew Balpien for long, since the time of Elf Circle in Second life in 2006, and later on in Inworldz. I was holding him as a good person, a friend, and a talented programmer, despite his apparent inability to work with other persons. But nobody is perfect!

In Discovery, I was at once offered a place to continue the Elf Dream meetings, by my friend Xentor Antarix, who had a large science fiction roleplay region. This gave me some time to create a region specifically dedicated to the Elves. This is how Daur Anarie was born, «wood clearing born from love», a tropical paradise with a large rock, an atoll and several smaller islands around. For two years it was my main creation focus, until Halcyon worlds restarted being available in 2019. But I was keeping it, at least until Halcyon hopefully stabilizes again.

However I realized that something was amiss again, when Balpien removed my character Richard Trigaux, whom I had created for my sciences activities. (A virtual murder, then). Balpien had just deleted it without any consideration of the elements he may detain, under an incredible pretext: that it would be «illegal» to have our real name in the virtual!

From this time, logging in the payment pages for my rent was more and more difficult. I did not realized yet, but Balpien likely had removed me from the payment system. But I am obstinate, and my rent finally passed with another method, while Balpien was saying that those problems happened «only to me» (Always be wary of somebody saying that). This October 2021, I could not log again, even with copy-pasting my password. No mail recovery either. I used the previous alternative route to order an OAR (safe copy of the region in a single file). Just after downloading it, I got a message from Balpien, saying that he had removed my region! Yes he had suppressed the elven island born from love, the Buddhist stupa and several light temples, this time pretending that ordering a safe copy is wanting to leave!

I also learned that Balpien was not the true creator of Discovery Grid, but Gregg Legendary. The later explained me how Balpien worked against him, using Gregg's difficulties in life, and his better technical knowledge, to enter into the payment system of Discovery Grid, and take a total control on it. Probably two other friends involved in the creation, Tenbear Running and Kayaker Magic, were also more or less discouraged, as I was no longer seeing them in the end.

This is a sad story on how Discovery Grid, technically the best Open Sims thanks to Balpien's programming skills, is now losing repute and regions. I have no idea of why Balpien was so hateful, but sure it is very sad for somebody who lived among virtual Elves, and has contacts with spirituality in his physical life.

This mishap clearly illustrates the problem which was to become the main limitation of virtual worlds: the master of the world complex, in a person who holds all the powers, technical, financial, community, without any moral, technical or legal limit. This person then starts to want to bend everybody to his law, when in fact a virtual world is a shared Internet hosting (on the same server) between people who each have their own project. With of course the virtual murder and the destruction of our work, as a way to achieve his ends, even from pure hatred, delirium or sadistic amusement.

 

The troubled rebirth of Halcyon:
Amaryllis and Enchanted

(Permalink) As of today, the story is not really written yet, so I keep vague on several points, which perspective may change.

The success of Halcyon could not go unnoticed. So there have been attempts to rebuild virtual worlds based on Halcyon.

If we pass Islandz, the first one was Amaryllis Grid, by Shadows Hunter. The success was mixed, for several reasons. But at least we got to restart something! So I resumed my elven meetings, on Friday, in addition to Saturday in Discovery Grid. Indeed, cautious, I kept this base as a fallback.

Things went not bad, but Shadow, sick and grieving for his dead wife, let a couple, Gem and Dai (Dawn Gemma Sian Rhys-Owain and Dai Rhys-Owain) take management positions. They first seemed very gracious, but we quickly felt a trouble when interacting with them, especially with their maniacal habit of deleting forum posts with or without reasons.

In fact, they lied to everybody, claiming that Shadows would not manage Amaryllis properly. So they created their own world: Enchanted Grid, and surreptitiously lured in all the residents of Amaryllis! With OARs to support the move, allowing to find our regions back exactly.

Enchanted was a huge success, far surpassing Amaryllis. Many of the old Inworldz members joined, but also new ones.

Mention must be made here of the work done by Vinhold Starbrook (Bob Curtice), and his Mundos Market project, which would provide all creators with a permanent fallback base, even if a world disappears. Several technical innovations also allow their clients to retrieve their possessions in other worlds, if theirs closes. This project is not yet operational at this time, but it is advanced enough to be a useful working base.

 

Then again the growth slowed down, again showing a sneaky evil force at work. Posts disappearing from the forum, people stopping to appear in the world, and Gem's characteristic way of systematically blaming us for her own actions. Never trust anyone doing that!

Enchanted was smelling more and more of rotten stuff under the carpet, and this is when Balpien kicked me out of Discovery Grid. This led to a discussion with Vinhold and several other people, towards a multiple world project without central power, or with separation of powers. To end up once and for all with the «complex of the master of the world». (abuses by world owners)

Then the unthinkable happened: Gem and Dai got into an dispute with the other members of the management team (Tanya Matahari, Artemis and Raven). Gem deleted all the discussions and expelled several people, including the main developer! Then the servers were shut down, probably out of pure hate. Gem claims that this is because of a «litigation», without explanation (Situation on October 29, 2021). Anyway, the company's servers being in Gem's personal name (Heavy fault!!), there is little hope of them reopening, nor even of recovering our regions. All this without worrying about months of work of several hundred innocent people. Not to mention that she was in a position to steal all our intellectual property.

Not the least evil, they accused one member of Enchanted of being «the cause» why they closed the servers!! Useless to say, our full support goes to that member.

Such a forfeit created a huge shock, which is still going on as I write this (October 28, 2021).

As I write, things are still fuzzy: new world project without «master of the world», boost to the Mundos Market, lawsuit against the Rhys-Owain, and other repercussions. Those two cybercriminals already are banned from several virtual worlds, their repute totally destroyed.

However, I also feel a great deal of positive energy rising behind all that. Karma engineering, as my Buddhist monk friends say. We shall see, perhaps soon.

 

 

Amithaba sand mandala, being dissolved and then reappearing spontaneously

Tompanyi To Gyur -- Tompey Nang Ney

(Amithaba sand mandala, Wesak 2018, Mahatare Buddhist centre, Singapore)

 

Sovaria Estates

(Permalink) This is the new Halcyon world, which is being created, with separation of powers, to avoid the « master of the world» complex. This name was made public on November 2, 2021, for opening in some days.

November 11: Sovaria shall be a non-profit organization, after the USA law. The site, and the login URI: connect.sovariaestates.world:8002.